mercer.co.uk & bounce.co.uk

Whois-Search · 08-12-2006, 12:41:25 PM

As you maybe aware the DRS appeal for mercer.co.uk is now out:

mercer.co.uk Appeal

The result: Overturned No Action

Would anyone like to have a go at comparing this to the bounce.co.uk DRS Appeal?

bounce.co.uk Appeal

i.e. what could the registrant have done in this case to keep the name as in the mercer.co.uk case.

Also.....

On the DRS review there are three options for fees:

Updating the .uk Dispute Resolution Service

Number 3 says "Introduce a system where the losing party pays for the decision".

In the case of mercer.co.uk the defendant lost the DRS but won on the Appeal.

So if this was implemented:

Who would pay the Appeal fee? Or does this only apply to the DRS complaint fee?

Would the defendant have to pay the DRS fee and the Appeal fee?

Also why is the appeal fee �3000 + VAT - why isn't it �750 x 3 experts = �2250 + VAT ?

P.S. before anyone says so yes I posted this on Nom-steer to

08-12-2006, 12:41:25 PM	#1 (permalink)
Whois-Search Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Swad.com Posts: 1,480 No Classified Ratings Domain Trader Rating: (100% / 2)	mercer.co.uk & bounce.co.uk As you maybe aware the DRS appeal for mercer.co.uk is now out: mercer.co.uk Appeal The result: Overturned No Action Would anyone like to have a go at comparing this to the bounce.co.uk DRS Appeal? bounce.co.uk Appeal i.e. what could the registrant have done in this case to keep the name as in the mercer.co.uk case. Also..... On the DRS review there are three options for fees: Updating the .uk Dispute Resolution Service Number 3 says "Introduce a system where the losing party pays for the decision". In the case of mercer.co.uk the defendant lost the DRS but won on the Appeal. So if this was implemented: Who would pay the Appeal fee? Or does this only apply to the DRS complaint fee? Would the defendant have to pay the DRS fee and the Appeal fee? Also why is the appeal fee �3000 + VAT - why isn't it �750 x 3 experts = �2250 + VAT ? P.S. before anyone says so yes I posted this on Nom-steer to __________________ Andrew Bennett - www.whois-search.com Linkedin: http://uk.linkedin.com/in/andrewgbennett

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Domain Name Community	Replies	Last Post
privalige.co.uk & mercer.co.uk appeals	Whois-Search	Domain Name Disputes	21	08-12-2006 07:21:13 PM
bounce.co.uk - Public Statement from Nominet	Beasty	Domain Name Disputes	11	28-09-2006 02:28:30 PM
mercer.co.uk DRS	Whois-Search	Domain Name Disputes	39	04-09-2006 05:45:40 PM
Bounce.co.uk appeal decision	michaeltoth	Domain Name Disputes	65	22-07-2006 04:14:14 AM
bounce.co.uk as a brand	grandin	Domain Name Disputes	0	28-06-2006 04:55:27 AM