I don't know about pigeon but what I have seen over the last few weeks is the same players now dominating the first page for many search terms, squeezing out the small independent companies which is a real shame. Google is slowly going to shit.
The main players I'm talking about are
yell
thomson local
free index
gumtree
I'm fecked off seeing the same shit on page 1
Google is becoming a directory of search directories.
Quite ironic though. If this is the long term shape of things to come, it could be google's demise.
Anything to do the a "trade - city" is dominated by the above. People will become brainwashed (as they are at present with google) to the same sites and slowly bypass google and go straight to yell (or one of the others) to do their search.
For tradesmen, you now need to be in the above as well as google if you want to pick up new customers via the net.
I'm not sure if Bing will survive, I heard somewhere that it is making a big yearly loss.
Whilst I share the frustrations, I can see why the big brands get better positions, there are more quality signals for those sites in most instance, they would also have bigger budgets for SEO.
Can't say I have but I don't have any type of local site
I did notice yesterday that if you google "translate" it gives you a translation box right there in the search results, not sure how long that has been there