Personally I like looking at other developers' sites, and I wish others would share more of their urls
Yes but that doesn't mean everyone shares your thoughts and wishes, and also all your sites look identical so I always think I have seen it before anyway, when you post one of yours - it is like looking at a twin with different colour eyes to the other twin.
- Yes, it might have a little SEO benefit, but that's probably minimal.
If you truly believed they were minimal, you would not be adding anchor text to them in the first place on every link you post
- It reminds me that I have the site, and perhaps it could do with a "brush up".
Brush up on what ? all your sites are the same ?
I have seen that woman's face so many times, I feel like I know her but couldn't think how I knew her !
Was she from a one night stand I had, before I was married ?
Was it that lady who serves me in Mcdonalds but looks different with her baseball cap on ?
Was it someone who I had glanced at in a passing car on the same route every day ?
Does she normally wear a burka, and it is the eyes I recognise, and not the face ?
Was she the star of the "webuyanycar.... dot com" advert ?
but then I realised I have seen her numerous times before :
http://www.computer-monitors.org.uk
http://www.reviewking.co.uk
http://www.etraveldeals.co.uk
http://www.findhotels.me.uk
http://www.bestukbroadband.co.uk
http://www.newmobilephone.net
http://www.cheapcarinsurancerocks.co.uk
Those are from your signature and are identical in look, usability and SEO
- For every hardened domainer of the old guard reading the post, there are probably a handful of unregistered "newbies" reading the post, and even though they can't say so, they probably find it quite helpful to see how the domain might be put to use.
I think even a newbie would have an idea of what products to promote on a domain like leathersofa.co.uk
- People evidently are interested in looking at sites, as so far the site has had 25 visits from this post.
Brilliant ! then you have probably achieved one of the objectives that you set out to do - get some extra traffic and maybe drop some untargetted cookies in the process also. I don't think they are interested, they are probably wondering if this is A N Other of your sites which looks exactly like the last one, except with a different domain name
- Sometimes I get offered link exchanges.
Brilliant again ! But you could post your sites in here
http://www.acorndomains.co.uk/search-engine-optimisation.html for that , as after all it is SEO benefits you are trying to achieve
- If somebody else has bought a domain, and I have a site on a similar theme, I do feel it is relevant to their request for appraisal. If I have a site, then it's a clear indication that I feel it is a worthwhile subject for a site.
So if more than one person has a site in the same niche, it MUST be a worthwhile subject ? are you saying every site you have built has always been a success and a worthile subject, as I know mine hasn't
I think anyone who needs reassurance by someone who thinks that by saying "I have one too" will make it a worthwhile purchase for them, shouldn't be involved in this game in the first place. The truth is though, the likes of people like SC2009 are not doing it for that reason. They are looking for honest opinions from people about HIS name - not someone else to say "hey I have one too, so it MUST be good"
Comparing leathersofas.me to leathersofa.co.uk is like comparing Basil Fawlty to Bill Gates "because they look the same age"
This may seem harsh, but the truth usually is. You do offer good advice and do go out of your way to help people in some posts, which I respect. But I am starting to think, that may be to get those extra links to all the sites in your signature, to help with your SEO.
This isn't personal against you, I would say the same to anyone who done this too
-----------------------------------------------------
Sorry to SC2009 for taking this off topic. For what it is worth, I think what you paid is around what it is worth undeveloped.
Developed and ranked, it will make a very pretty penny in monthly sales and commisions, and also a nice enduser buy out at some point