.UK Announced

foz · Oct 10, 2012

With regards to forum.nominet.org.uk. Do you think posts will be answered by Nominet? or we are just speaking to and amongst ourselves going around and around in circles?

Edwin · Oct 10, 2012

foz said:
With regards to forum.nominet.org.uk. Do you think posts will be answered by Nominet? or we are just speaking to and amongst ourselves going around and around in circles?

My instinct is that Nominet may READ them. We're not going to see any comment from them, but at least there's a chance of an audience unlike here on Acorn where I'd bet nobody from Nominet has visited in years.

It's unfortunate that some are expending more energy excoriating domain investors on Nominet's forum than they are debating the actual issue at hand. There's a disturbing mood of gleeful triumphalism at the thought that "domainers" may be the most affected. Hopefully it's just a vocal minority.

grantw · Oct 10, 2012

foz said:
With regards to forum.nominet.org.uk. Do you think posts will be answered by Nominet? or we are just speaking to and amongst ourselves going around and around in circles?

They very rarely get involved in discussions on there, was the same on the old Nomsteer mailing list.

As I'm sure you're witnessing, it's very hard to post on there as a domainer without someone going off an a domainer hate tangent!

Grant

foz · Oct 10, 2012

Edwin said:
My instinct is that Nominet may READ them. We're not going to see any comment from them, but at least there's a chance of an audience unlike here on Acorn where I'd bet nobody from Nominet has visited in years.

It's unfortunate that some are expending more energy excoriating domain investors on Nominet's forum than they are debating the actual issue at hand. There's a disturbing mood of gleeful triumphalism at the thought that "domainers" may be the most affected. Hopefully it's just a vocal minority.

Thanks. Would be good if more Nominet members from all areas of the .uk business commented on the forum. I'm suspecting that a lot are unaware of its existence?

Yes, the jives are being hurled every which way. Do they really think they will have an influence on us in changing our profession by going on and on and on and on about it. Hardly.

rhaigh · Oct 10, 2012

Bailey said:
My comments were in fact directed to rhaigh

Please enlighten me, pointing out the things I have
said that are incorrect...

Thanks,

foz · Oct 10, 2012

grantw said:
They very rarely get involved in discussions on there, was the same on the old Nomsteer mailing list.

Grant

Righto. Legal implications maybe.

anthony · Oct 10, 2012

Edwin said:
...at least there's a chance of an audience unlike here on Acorn where I'd bet nobody from Nominet has visited in years.

Daniel Kelleher is here almost daily. He never posts of course, but at least he has the balls to use his own name, and hopefully his own email address too!

philiporchard · Oct 10, 2012

Graeme, tried to email but message bounced. Please can you PM me your contact details. Thanks, phil

GreyWing · Oct 10, 2012

philiporchard said:
Graeme, tried to email but message bounced. Please can you PM me your contact details. Thanks, phil

No problem mate just emailed it to you, if anyone else needs me it is

help (at) greywing.co.uk

viceroy · Oct 10, 2012

Edwin said:
My instinct is that Nominet may READ them. We're not going to see any comment from them, but at least there's a chance of an audience unlike here on Acorn where I'd bet nobody from Nominet has visited in years.

It's unfortunate that some are expending more energy excoriating domain investors on Nominet's forum than they are debating the actual issue at hand. There's a disturbing mood of gleeful triumphalism at the thought that "domainers" may be the most affected. Hopefully it's just a vocal minority.

Just out of interest, how many Nom members are there and what proportion would you define as investors rather than just registrars? I think that it is just a vocal minority at the moment because only registrars have been notified of the proposals ( as far as I'm aware) while the 11 mil+ registrants "should check the Nominet website every now and again if they're interested in their domain names".
I know of 2 companies (with £100 mil+ turnover) with relatively generic domain names that they operate from and they have no idea "what i'm going on about and how the hell would there even be a small chance that this Nominet organisation not let them have their names in .uk, especially after we've put so much into our name already".

Edwin · Oct 10, 2012

viceroy said:
Just out of interest, how many Nom members are there and what proportion would you define as investors rather than just registrars? I think that it is just a vocal minority at the moment because only registrars have been notified of the proposals ( as far as I'm aware) while the 11 mil+ registrants "should check the Nominet website every now and again if they're interested in their domain names".
I know of 2 companies (with £100 mil+ turnover) with relatively generic domain names that they operate from and they have no idea "what i'm going on about and how the hell would there even be a small chance that this Nominet organisation not let them have their names in .uk, especially after we've put so much into our name already".

I think it's about 4,000 members. Here's the current list (the old page is 404 but I managed to find this one) http://www.nominet.org.uk/whoweare/structure/members/list-members

If I had to guess - and it would be no more than that - I'd say perhaps 250-300 members are domain investors and perhaps the same again are registrars (with some overlap) and the rest are organisations that joined Nominet to have internal control over their domain name portfolios for greater security and accountability, web development firms, etc.

However (and this is a BIG difference) the registrars have perhaps 90%+ of the voting power because it's based on domains-on-tags and of course the big registrars have hundreds of thousands each.

If somebody has any better figures, I'm all ears - not suggesting my guess is particularly accurate.

Ashton · Oct 10, 2012

Edwin said:
I think it's about 4,000 members. Here's the current list http://www.nominet.org.uk/whoweare/structure/members/list-members

Weird, we're not on there.

anthony · Oct 10, 2012

viceroy said:
Just out of interest, how many Nom members are there and what proportion would you define as investors rather than just registrars? I think that it is just a vocal minority at the moment because only registrars have been notified of the proposals ( as far as I'm aware) while the 11 mil+ registrants "should check the Nominet website every now and again if they're interested in their domain names".
I know of 2 companies (with £100 mil+ turnover) with relatively generic domain names that they operate from and they have no idea "what i'm going on about and how the hell would there even be a small chance that this Nominet organisation not let them have their names in .uk, especially after we've put so much into our name already".

Like L'Oreal perhaps? Take skincare.co.uk (amongst other generics they have). It'll be interesting to see if Corporates like this are able to replicate their generic portfolios, even partially!

Edwin · Oct 10, 2012

anthony said:
Like L'Oreal perhaps? Take skincare.co.uk (amongst other generics they have). It'll be interesting to see if Corporates like this are able to replicate their generic portfolios, even partially!

Or any of these companies...
http://www.memorabledomains.co.uk/companies-that-get-it.html
http://www.memorabledomains.co.uk/more-companies-that-get-it.html

GreyWing · Oct 10, 2012

2880'ish members of Nominet as of the AGM in April, roughly will be about that figure according to my data on voting rights.

tifosi · Oct 10, 2012

Even with the cap on voting rights if the top 3 fanboy registrars vote the same way then it's a fait accompli.

GreyWing · Oct 11, 2012

tifosi said:
Even with the cap on voting rights if the top 3 fanboy registrars vote the same way then it's a fait accompli.

It is complicated mate, technically they are limited to capped to 3%. So 3*3%=9% in theory. There are other brands of course under those three big boys so you could be right, not sure.

If they did squash it with 3 big boys then that is effectively saying that the UK internet is under the control of 3 big boys. That equally won't look good for Nominet in the eyes of the Government.

I still think it is in everyone's interests not to try and get board level conflict with Nominet, that is still the aim of everyone. So just trying to answer your question in theory rather than say what anyone needs to do to cause conflict, if you get what I mean. Voting rights are very complicated.

----

I'm doing articles on sites that will lose out if these changes go ahead. I'd be grateful if anyone knows of any to fill in the form on the page. The bigger the better and there are some big ones already.

http://www.that.co.uk/business/known-victims.html

foz · Oct 11, 2012

Via email. Posting in case you did not receive it.

Direct.uk consultation update - dates for the diary.

We would like to thank all those who have already taken the time to give us their feedback to the consultation on the proposed new direct.uk service.

We have an FAQ available to provide further clarification on some of the questions stakeholders have asked. (http://www.nominet.org.uk/how-parti...y-discussions-and-consultations/direct-uk-faq)

We recognise that the proposals would represent significant change for the .uk domain name space, and have set up a number of different opportunities to get involved and ensure that any resulting service or changes would meet the needs of businesses, boost trust in the .uk namespace, and contribute positively to Britain's fast-growing internet economy.

1. Roundtables

We have organised three roundtable meetings for stakeholders in London to ensure we capture feedback from a number of specific perspectives.

You can sign up for the session dedicated to registrars on Tuesday 6 November 2012, 10.30 - 13.00 http://www.keysurvey.co.uk/f/463415/161e/

We expect these meetings to be popular so would encourage you to register your interest as soon as possible. Only one representative per organisation will be accepted for each session.

There will be four further meetings that will be open to all:

* 14 November in Cardiff
* 28 November in Glasgow
* 4 December in Manchester
* 11 December in Belfast

Register your interest in attending these: http://www.keysurvey.co.uk/f/463417/172a/

2. Open House

To answer specific questions you may have about the proposals, we will be holding an 'Open House' on 8 November 2012 in London. Nominet staff will be on hand to discuss specific aspects of the proposed direct.uk service, including malware scanning, registrant contact detail verification, plans for sunrise period and dispute resolution. If you would like to attend please register your details: http://www.keysurvey.co.uk/f/463415/161e/

3. .uk Registrar Conference

This year's .uk registrar conference will be held on Wednesday 21 November 10.30 - 13.30 in London and will focus on the implications of this potential new service. If you are interested in attending please register your details http://www.keysurvey.co.uk/f/463469/fe5f/

The event will be webcast for those unable to attend in person. If you are interested in joining the webcast please register your details http://www.keysurvey.co.uk/f/463488/d90a/

4. Respond to the consultation

You can view the proposals and respond to the consultation either by completing an online form, by downloading the consultation and return your completed form to [email protected] or by requesting a printed copy of the consultation from [email protected].

5. Twitter, blog and email

We will be providing regular updates about the consultation on Twitter and on our blog. We will also be sending email updates, if you have registered to receive them at http://www.nominet.org.uk/how-parti.../how-uk-policy-process-works/register-updates

The consultation is open until 7th January 2013.

If you have any questions regarding this please contact our Customer Services team on 01865 332233 or email [email protected]
--
Nominet UK Announcement mailing list
http://www.nominet.org.uk/go/lists