privalige.co.uk & mercer.co.uk appeals

Whois-Search · Oct 11, 2006

The appeal of privalige.co.uk is now on Nominet's website:

http://www.nic.uk/digitalAssets/9377_privalige_appeal___question_answer.pdf

No action surprise surprise.

Also looks like mercer.co.uk is going to appeal:

Decisions

Transfer
Appeal Pending

Think i'll give up domaining and become a ip lawyer ! it pays more.

grandin · Oct 11, 2006

Ha

Oh yes Nominet...

Nominet states on this case 'Nominet recognises that experts may on occasion make mistakes'

My comment in respect to generic domain names 'Nominet doesn't recognise (through the policy) that registrants may on occassion make mistakes when using their domain names'

When experts make mistakes we should transfer their expert title to another....keep it fair

Lee

sneezycheese · Oct 13, 2006

grandin said:
My comment in respect to generic domain names 'Nominet doesn't recognise (through the policy) that registrants may on occassion make mistakes when using their domain names'

...Therefore I ask - Can the Nominet Contract be voidable under the Doctrine of Mistake??? :???:

Regards,

Sneezy.

Creature · Oct 13, 2006

grandin said:
Oh yes Nominet...

Nominet states on this case 'Nominet recognises that experts may on occasion make mistakes'

My comment in respect to generic domain names 'Nominet doesn't recognise (through the policy) that registrants may on occassion make mistakes when using their domain names'

When experts make mistakes we should transfer their expert title to another....keep it fair

Lee

Agreed. Apply the rule to everyone.

grandin · Oct 13, 2006

story time

I will tell you a little story soon...trading standards

\lee

ELIFE-MZ · Dec 8, 2006

Looks like mercer decision has been overturned. Well done Chris.

Appeals

retired_member6 · Dec 8, 2006

invincible said:
Noticed that earlier. Hope he felt it was worth the £3000.

Well they can sue them now and get the £3k back.

sneezycheese · Dec 8, 2006

It's interesting to note that looking at the overall appeal results that 53% of 'expert' decisions that have gone to appeal have been overturned - so not a good picture.

More interesting is that for this year alone the percentage of 'expert' decisions that have gone to appeal and have been overtured is a WOPPING 83% - !!!

Surly Nominet 'must' be getting the message now! :???:

Roll on the new year! :mrgreen:

Regards,

Sneezy.

Jay Daley · Dec 8, 2006

grandin said:
I will tell you a little story soon...trading standards

No, don't worry Lee, we're okay. Really. No need. Honestly.

retired_member6 · Dec 8, 2006

invincible said:
Somehow, I doubt it. Mind if I rattle off one of my old favourites which is "cost of doing business"? :mrgreen:

Well I'm sure they can claim the £3k back somehow, that's how courts work right? if you have to defend yourself you can claim costs back after winning, I 'kin would after spending £3k, they're clearly wrong it's been judged now it's get your money back time.

I know you're rich enough to put everything in costs of business but others can be made to go to the wall (not Millwall - fortunately for them) over decisions by these arses. Where's the deterrant if the defendent doesn't go after monies from the complainant? So yes you all sit back spend your £3ks like it's going out of fashion and let complainants think it's that easy.

sneezycheese · Dec 8, 2006

Jay Daley said:
No, don't worry Lee, we're okay.

...of course you are Jay - lets not worry about a thing - why don't you cosy up in your little blanket of... ??? - Ah bless.

rob · Dec 8, 2006

sneezycheese said:
...of course you are Jay - lets not worry about a thing - why don't you cosy up in your little blanket of... ??? - Ah bless.

blankets? Hes in sao paulo currently... bang "sao paulo women" into google image search.

I know which I would be cosying up to

sneezycheese · Dec 8, 2006

rob said:
I know which I would be cosying up to

...mmm - me too!

:mrgreen:

weycresto · Dec 8, 2006

Sorry I've been asleep. Whats this? They have decided to spend Nominets cash on sao paulo women now? Maybe thats really where the "mizz" tags really hang out!

rob · Dec 8, 2006

weycresto said:
Sorry I've been asleep. Whats this? They have decided to spend Nominets cash on sao paulo women now? Maybe thats really where the "mizz" tags really hang out!

ICANN São Paulo ::

weycresto · Dec 8, 2006

Very nice - I 'll make do with Canning Town thankyou.

grandin · Dec 8, 2006

Trading Standards

Jay, why are you replying to a post of many days ago?

Are you implying that you have just been given the all clear from Trading Standards i.e. that you are ok to sell the current contract to your consumers?

Lee

Hazel Pegg · Dec 8, 2006

grandin said:
Jay, why are you replying to a post of many days ago?

Maybe his wireless broadband connection dropped somewhere between Heathrow and Sao Paulo?

Hazel

Jay Daley · Dec 8, 2006

grandin said:
Jay, why are you replying to a post of many days ago?

Actually I didn't realise it was that old. But as far as I know there is no time limit here?

grandin said:
Are you implying that you have just been given the all clear from Trading Standards i.e. that you are ok to sell the current contract to your consumers?

I think it is best we don't get into that one. Mainly because I don't understand what the point is but also because I think I'm not really the right person to ask.