Drag and Drop - which is best?

[philiporchardphiliporchard is verified member.]

Hi,

Just deciding between two Drag and Drop alternatives.

In the first example, the shape reduces in size when dropped
http://www.beths-homework.co.uk/example-4.mp4

In the second example, the shape remains the same size.
http://www.beths-homework.co.uk/example-5.mp4

Any thoughts on which is preferable, or no preference?

Thanks in advance.

 

[SkinnerSkinner is verified member.]

I like the first one. Looks more natural once in place.

 

[humble pie]

first one much cleaner

 

[philiporchardphiliporchard is verified member.]

Yes, we did wonder if 6 year olds on Ipads, might find the 'draggable token' became a little too small in the first example.

Thanks for thoughts - much appreciated.

 

[scottmccloud]

Definitely the first one.

 

[diablo]

Just asked two seven year old twins for you. Both said the second one!

UPDATE: Neither knew what an adjective was however!

 

[philiporchardphiliporchard is verified member.]

Great - thanks for that!

Useful to get some children's input for sure!