Membership is FREE, giving all registered users unlimited access to every Acorn Domains feature, resource, and tool! Optional membership upgrades unlock exclusive benefits like profile signatures with links, banner placements, appearances in the weekly newsletter, and much more - customized to your membership level!

.UK Announced

Its good to know they thought this through properly, what a bunch of numpties they are at nominet.


Remember this is still a consultation. Nominet will probably have some ideas of different options but until the consultation has ended I would be surprised if Nominet release much detail. If the consultation works well then they will have a full range of ideas and evidence from which to develop a workable way forward or otherwise. I would imagine, if the proposal still continues, that there could be a second round of consultation on a more worked-up version of this or perhaps the setting up of some kind of working / technical group with stakeholders to progress this.

Stephen.
 
Out of interest who is attending the registrar day on Wednesday? Who's registered for the webcast?

I was hoping to go, but realistically it is going to be too close for a meeting later in the day that I've already cancelled three times !

I am registered for the webcast though and have had login confirmed.

Dave
 
Out of interest who is attending the registrar day on Wednesday? Who's registered for the webcast?

I'm registered for the webcast. You won't catch me further south than Watford Gap, can't be doing with all them pearly kings and bowler hats :)

Grant
 
Not sure if anyone has posted but can someone please point me in the direction of the webcast registration please.
 
" As it is not decided whether a direct.uk service will proceed, or if it does the form the service might take,
it is simply not possible to provide answers to your questions on implementation, strategy, marketing communications,
or how any changes to terms and conditions might manifest themselves. "

Ah give them a break - 10 people in Trump_Nom Towers must be working overtime as because they may have realised it has :

a. Not been thought through properly;
b. Not been communicated properly;
c. Not been considered that anyone may have opposing opinions to the views of Nom directors;
d. Not been thought through properly!

I decided to add one point twice as there are sooooo many gaping holes when you probe the surface of these "initial" proposals.

Be good to know how much cash Nom have spent on lawyers, external consultants and time to get to where it is today as either :

a. They have been ripped off and the Nominet Trust has lost a lot of money for what is a ill-conceived and half-arsed consultation to date

OR

b. They have spent nothing (so the Trust is fine) which would make sense given what they have put on the table has clearly not been run past anyone outside the boardroom.

Summary

IMHO, it is complete BS that a company that is this far down the track of a 'consultation' cannot answer questions about implementation, strategy, marketing communications, or how any changes to terms and conditions might manifest themselves.

So are they serisouly saying that as a board/company they are proposing something that we, the shareholders, can't question their authority and processes and must go along with them 'blind' and 'hope for the best'?

Those questions are some of the very first basic things any internal management (worth their salt) or external consultant would ask as it's what the members/shareholders need to know in order to even vote yes or no with any conviction.

Nom really are looking like a bunch of prize numpties and everyone at a senior level will be tarred with the same brush.

TW
 
What do you see?

d. Not been thought through properly!....
Those questions are some of the very first basic things any internal management (worth their salt) or external consultant would ask as it's what the members/shareholders need to know in order to even vote yes or no with any conviction.

I'm glad I am not alone in my assessment!

After 4 weeks nearly full time, on researching .uk, I'm wondering why Nominet do not see this as well?
 
I'm glad I am not alone in my assessment!

After 4 weeks nearly full time, on researching .uk, I'm wondering why Nominet do not see this as well?

££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££

Could be the answer :)
 
But as they said

"As it is not decided whether a direct.uk service will proceed....."

As far as I can see you can't really complain about the number of opportunities that Nominet are giving to listening to stakeholder views (at least for those in the know). Consultations are about listening not having a dialogue - that should come at the next stage.

Stephen.
 
But as they said

"As it is not decided whether a direct.uk service will proceed....."

As far as I can see you can't really complain about the number of opportunities that Nominet are giving to listening to stakeholder views (at least for those in the know). Consultations are about listening not having a dialogue - that should come at the next stage.

Stephen.

So you think that there will be a next stage prior to implementation.
If that was the case surely they would have made it clear so as to appease the dissenters.
 
So you think that there will be a next stage prior to implementation.
If that was the case surely they would have made it clear so as to appease the dissenters.

Well I don't know for sure - but given the amound of dissention is it clear that it would be madness to not properly address the many arguments (good and bad) that have been put forward by various parties. The opposition and interest might have come as a surprise to them, on the other hand they might expected it, but either way it will have been noted.

I don't have strong views either way about the proposal but for those are very against this I would be concerned that the mainstream media and big business groups have yet to be heard coming out against (apart from a select one or two industry bloggers and attendees at the small Nominet events).

Stephen.
 
Well I don't know for sure - but given the amound of dissention is it clear that it would be madness to not properly address the many arguments (good and bad) that have been put forward by various parties. The opposition and interest might have come as a surprise to them, on the other hand they might expected it, but either way it will have been noted.

I don't have strong views either way about the proposal but for those are very against this I would be concerned that the mainstream media and big business groups have yet to be heard coming out against (apart from a select one or two industry bloggers and attendees at the small Nominet events).

Stephen.
.

My gut feeling is that it won't matter if people like you and me agree or not.
Nominet know that they can sell 7 or 8 million of these domains and the only thing that will stop them is if they are not, for whatever reason, allowed to do it.

It's similar to the large corporations tax avoidance scandal, the argument is that it's legal.
 
Well I don't know for sure - but given the amound of dissention is it clear that it would be madness to not properly address the many arguments (good and bad) that have been put forward by various parties. The opposition and interest might have come as a surprise to them, on the other hand they might expected it, but either way it will have been noted.

Before such a consultation research should have been conducted, they are running with something that is poorly put together and though out. Generating more revenues is the only fuel.

The fact they have chopped and changed the summary blurb, consultation document and FAQ's section as time passes demonstrates this.
 
Britain is England, Scotland, Wales.
UK is England, Scotland, Wales, N. Ireland.

If Scotland does go independent, I'm sure Nominet will be on the ball and release .gb as the NEW new top domain for British business :D

UK and Britain are the same are they not?

UK: United Kingdom. United Kingdom of what? United Kingdom of :gd Britain.
 

The Rule #1

Do not insult any other member. Be polite and do business. Thank you!

Members online

Premium Members

New Threads

Domain Forum Friends

Our Mods' Businesses

*the exceptional businesses of our esteemed moderators
General chit-chat
Help Users
  • No one is chatting at the moment.
      There are no messages in the current room.
      Top Bottom