As a forum member I was after the opinion of other members of the forum, which I am not able to get if its hidden from members.
I agreed to buy domains which was acknowledged, the domains were then sold to another person. I don't think leaving a negative trader review is suitable for something of this nature and the member should either be banned or lose selling rights.
I never received an email notifying me of your reply either, only an email from the first reply to the post.